Establishing a cohesive structure of play at Manchester United is essential for success in football, as demonstrated by examples such as Jurgen Klopp at Liverpool and Pep Guardiola at Manchester City.
The statement that the players are not good enough at Manchester United is often made, but it misses the crucial point that the coach must first establish the structure of play that they want to see at the club. Only then can they sign players who fit that style.
The new coach needs to put their principles in place before players can be signed to fit it. This is exactly what was expected of Erik Ten Hag, the current boss at Old Trafford, but he stated that he did not come to play the same style of football that the club and fans were attracted to in the first place.
09:13 - 28.02.2024
‘He’s a machine’ — Manchester United legend lauds five-star Erling Haaland
The Manchester City forward netted five in the Cityzens’ 6-2 FA Cup 5th Round win over Luton Town at Kenilworth Road.
18:47 - 27.02.2024
Five problems Erik ten Hag is facing at Old Trafford
After the Fulham game, Erik ten Hag is facing several challenges at Manchester United, highlighting areas that need immediate attention to steer the club back on course.
Manchester United's struggles
The Red Devils have struggled to control matches and in the last five matches have conceded a remarkable 100 shots against teams like Luton Town, Fulham, and Aston Villa in that run.
It is important to note that control is a style, and it is the coach who instils that style. Teams like Middlesbrough, Ipswich Town, managed by ex-United backroom staff and coaches, Michael Carrick and Kieran McKenna, and even Manchester City, pre-Guardiola, were not playing the dominant football we watch them play now until the right coach came in and instilled their style.
Therefore, it is not about the players, but rather the structure that is needed to play the desired style of football. Once the structure is in place, players can be signed to fit it.
A good example of this is Jurgen Klopp at Liverpool. He did not start his journey with Mohamed Salah, Trent Alexander-Arnold, and Robertson. Instead, he established his principles and gradually replaced players who did not fit those principles.
This is what Guardiola did at Manchester City, and it is what Xabi Alonso or Julian Nagelsmann now linked to OT, would need to do if they end up at Manchester United under the management of Sir Jim Ratcliffe.
Therefore, instead of blaming the players, the new coach needs to establish a structure that fits their desired style of play and gradually replace players who do not fit that structure. This is the most important thing, and it is what will lead to success at the club.
Related content
09:13 - 28.02.2024
‘He’s a machine’ — Manchester United legend lauds five-star Erling Haaland
The Manchester City forward netted five in the Cityzens’ 6-2 FA Cup 5th Round win over Luton Town at Kenilworth Road.
09:08 - 28.02.2024
They have the perfect connection — Guardiola praises star duo after FA Cup win
Manchester City demolished Luton Town 6-2 in an eagerly anticipated FA Cup fifth-round tie on Tuesday night.
05:53 - 28.02.2024
De Bruyne matches and outdoes Jota’s assists feat against Luton Town
The Manchester City attacking midfielder set up four of Erling Haaland’s five goals as Pep Guardiola’s men stormed into the FA Cup quarter-finals with a 6-2 win at Kenilworth Road.
21:50 - 27.02.2024
FOOTBALL Manchester United players clash with coaches after Fulham fiasco
Some Manchester United players requested a day off after losing to Fulham amid Erik ten Hag's uncertain future and management turmoil.
21:49 - 27.02.2024
I don't want him punished — Greenwood opens up on feelings after Bellingham's alleged name-calling
Mason Greenwood urges Spanish FA to dismiss Jude Bellingham slur case.
21:26 - 27.02.2024
Wayne Rooney bags new job following Birmingham sack
Wayne Rooney joins BBC Sport as pundit for Manchester United's FA Cup clash against Nottingham Forest.
17:42 - 27.02.2024
Chelsea's £1bn mistake? Ranking all of Boehly's transfers from Best Buys to Biggest Bloopers
Chelsea have signed a total of 24 players since Todd Boehly took over from Roman Abrahamovic, but how many of them have been success stories?
16:58 - 27.02.2024
Pochettino reveals conversation with Todd Boehly after Carabao Cup final defeat to Liverpool
Chelsea boss Mauricio Pochettino has opened up on the conversation he had with club co-owner Todd Boehly following the Carabao Cup final defeat to Liverpool.
16:19 - 27.02.2024
Ranking The Greatest Centre-Backs in Premier League history
Legends from Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool and both Manchester clubs make the list of the most elite centre-backs that have played in the Premier League
15:58 - 27.02.2024
Ten Hag hits back at Liverpool icon’s criticism of his Manchester United side
Manchester United head coach Erik ten Hag has criticised Jamie Carragher's lack of objectivity after the pundit's scathing analysis of the Red Devils on Sky Sports’ Monday Night Football.