Fans believe referee Joh Brooks made a mistake in ruling out the first goal for Manchester United against Fulham, but upon further inspection, Scott McTominay's effort was correctly ruled out
Manchester United escaped a sticky situation against Fulham in their Saturday fixture as captain Bruno Fernandes rescued the Red Devils with a late goal.
Manchester United have goal ruled out against Fulham
Fernandes’ 91st-minute goal was enough for Manchester United to scrape a 1-0 win, but a major talking point from the match was the decision to deny Manchester United an earlier opening goal.
15:43 - 04.11.2023
Captain fantastic Bruno Fernandes rescues Manchester United with late winner against Iwobi's Fulham
Bruno Fernandes was on hand to help Manchester United put Fulham and Super Eagles star Alex Iwobi to the sword with a late winner at Craven Cottage
14:01 - 04.11.2023
Ex-Man Utd star set for retirement at aged 35 following five years stint in China
Former Manchester United and Everton midfielder Marouane Fellaini is set to retire from football.
After just 11 minutes of Manchester United’s encounter with Fulham, the Red Devils thought they had taken the lead when Scott McTominay finished off a freekick routine that went through Fernandes and a cutback from Alejandro Garnacho.
The VAR officials decided that Harry Maguire had been offside in the build-up, despite the defender not touching the ball before the goal was scored.
Referee made the correct call
However, fans on social media have disagreed with the decision to rule out the goal, arguing that since Maguire did not touch the ball, he was not directly interfering with the eventual goal.
11:31 - 04.11.2023
Man Utd fans clamour for Mason Greenwood’s return following a successful start at Getafe
Mason Greenwood is wanted back by Manchester United supporters after his loan stint at Getafe.
23:55 - 03.11.2023
Unacceptable — Erik ten Hag slams Rashford for Partying after 3-0 defeat
Manchester United star Marcus Rashford faced criticism over partying after derby day defeat.
While these supporters will be expecting an apology letter from the Premier League’s refereeing body, PGMOL, that apology is unlikely to ever come since the goal was correctly ruled out by referee John Brooks.
Since Maguire was directly in the path of the Fulham defender closest to the ball and Garnacho, who eventually assisted the goal, the England international could be said to be interfering with play by stopping the Cottager’s last man from making an interception.
But for Maguire’s influence, it is unlikely that the ball would have gotten to Garnacho, meaning the former club captain played an active part in the eventual goal by McTominay.
The offside call was applied in the same way a goal could be ruled out when a player obstructs a goalkeeper’s line of sight, even when they do not directly touch the ball.
Therefore, the decision to rule out the goal was correct, despite the outcry of Manchester United fans.
Related content
15:43 - 04.11.2023
Captain fantastic Bruno Fernandes rescues Manchester United with late winner against Iwobi's Fulham
Bruno Fernandes was on hand to help Manchester United put Fulham and Super Eagles star Alex Iwobi to the sword with a late winner at Craven Cottage
14:01 - 04.11.2023
Ex-Man Utd star set for retirement at aged 35 following five years stint in China
Former Manchester United and Everton midfielder Marouane Fellaini is set to retire from football.
11:31 - 04.11.2023
Man Utd fans clamour for Mason Greenwood’s return following a successful start at Getafe
Mason Greenwood is wanted back by Manchester United supporters after his loan stint at Getafe.
10:20 - 04.11.2023
FOOTBALL Fulham vs Manchester United: Selection headache for under-fire Erik ten Hag as he seeks for some positive results after recent slide
Manchester United manager Erik ten Hag has mounting injuries to deal with at a time his side have been on a poor run of form but he will have to get a win at Fulham to ease some pressure
03:27 - 04.11.2023
Yaya Toure: Man City and Premier League legend gets coaching job in Saudi Arabia
Manchester City and Premier League great Yaya Toure has joined the revolution in Saudi Arabia.
23:55 - 03.11.2023
Unacceptable — Erik ten Hag slams Rashford for Partying after 3-0 defeat
Manchester United star Marcus Rashford faced criticism over partying after derby day defeat.
20:08 - 03.11.2023
Will Bassey and Iwobi heap more misery on Manchester United?
Before Fulham take on Manchester United, Pulse Sports analyse Calvin Bassey's recent performances in an unfamiliar position and examine Alex Iwobi’s showing at Brighton.
18:59 - 03.11.2023
Man United manager Erik Ten Hag rules out transfers despite bad form, insists his current squad is good
Erik ten Hag has stated that despite Manchester United's bad start to the season, he is not considering any transfers.
18:00 - 03.11.2023
FOOTBALL More problems for Manchester United as midfielder is ruled out for ‘several weeks’
The experienced midfielder will not be available for a number of weeks after suffering a hamstring injury in midweek